The Marmot Agate Tent: A lightweight backpacking shelter or an overpriced tarp? This review dives deep into the pros and cons of this unique shelter, examining its design, setup options, weather protection, and – crucially – its price. Weighing in at just over a pound, the Agate boasts a spacious interior for a single person, even offering room for two in a pinch. Its single-pole design, adaptable to trekking poles or the included pole, offers flexibility for ultralight adventures.However, this innovative design comes at a cost. At around $215, the Agate is significantly more expensive than comparable shelters. This review explores whether its lightweight design, generous interior space, and flexible setup justify the premium price. We'll analyze its performance in various weather conditions, compare it to similar options on the market, and ultimately help you decide if the Marmot Agate is the right ultralight shelter for your backpacking needs.
Read more: 5 Best PVC Camping Tarps for Your Next Adventure
First Impressions: A Unique Shelter
The Marmot Agate is not your typical tent; it's more of a modified tarp. It boasts a single, unique shape, unlike traditional tarps with multiple pitching options. This design makes it more tent-like, but at a considerable cost.
Initial impressions are mixed. While the lightweight design (just over one pound) is appealing for solo backpacking, the price point seems quite high for what it offers.
The tent's dimensions are intriguing: a 42-inch peak height, 58 inches wide at the head, and 92 inches long overall. While potentially suitable for two, it's ideally suited as a minimalist single-person shelter.
Pitching Options and Weight Considerations
The Marmot Agate offers flexibility in setup. It can be pitched using trekking poles, resulting in a lightweight setup of approximately 17 ounces. Alternatively, it can be pitched with the included pole structure, adding about seven ounces to the total weight.
The trekking pole option is a compelling advantage for ultralight backpacking, allowing for a highly portable shelter. However, the added weight of the included pole structure should be considered if trekking poles aren't already part of your gear.
This flexibility in setup is a key strength, catering to different backpacking preferences and gear choices. The weight difference between the two options is significant enough to factor into the decision-making process.
Performance and Weather Protection
The tarp-style design of the Marmot Agate provides excellent weather protection, especially against wind and light rain. It's best suited for fair-weather trips, not intense storms. The large interior space makes it comfortable for solo camping.
The generous interior dimensions, especially the 50-inch width at the foot end, make the tent feel spacious. However, this design preference sacrifices some weather protection compared to more traditional tent shapes.
This shelter is perfect for those who prioritize weight savings over extreme weather protection on backpacking trips where light rain or wind is expected.
Cost and Value Analysis
The Marmot Agate's price is a significant drawback. At around $215 (without the optional $50 footprint), it's expensive for a lightweight tarp-style shelter. The added cost of trekking poles, if not already owned, further increases the overall expense.
Comparable shelters exist in similar weight ranges for considerably less. Therefore, the value proposition is questionable; there are more affordable alternatives offering similar performance.
While its features are appealing, the high price point makes it difficult to justify compared to more budget-friendly options that perform well in similar weather conditions.
Conclusion: Is It Worth It?
The Marmot Agate is a well-designed lightweight shelter, ideal for fair-weather backpacking trips. The flexibility of pitching options with or without trekking poles is a plus, but the high price tag is a serious deterrent.
Weighing the cost against its features, many similar shelters provide comparable performance at a lower price. Ultimately, whether it's worth the investment depends on individual priorities and budget.
Consider the Marmot Agate if ultralight weight is paramount and you prioritize a spacious, tarp-style shelter for good weather, but be prepared to pay a premium. Numerous alternatives offer similar weight and functionality for less money.