Lightweight camping tarps are a versatile alternative to traditional tents, offering significant weight savings and increased setup flexibility. Perfect for backpacking, canoe camping, or emergency situations, these shelters provide essential protection from the elements while minimizing pack weight. This review delves into a detailed comparison of two leading American-made brands: Equinox and Cook Custom Sewing. Both offer durable and high-performance tarps constructed from lightweight ripstop nylon, but with key differences in size, features, and price.This comparative analysis examines the strengths and weaknesses of each brand, exploring aspects like dimensions, weight, construction quality, and price point. We'll investigate the setup process, focusing on the versatile ridgeline system, and highlight unique features such as reinforced webbing loops and integrated paddle attachments. Ultimately, this review aims to help you decide which tarp best suits your needs and budget, whether you prioritize affordability or premium quality and enhanced functionality for your outdoor adventures.
Read more: 5 Best PVC Camping Tarps for Your Next Adventure
The Need for a Lightweight Tarp
While tents are the usual choice for camping shelters, lightweight tarps offer a versatile alternative, particularly for backpacking and canoe camping. They provide essential protection from rain and sun, and some tarps can be used to create a functional shelter for sleeping, ideal for emergency situations or personal preference. Tarps are incredibly lightweight, packing down smaller than even a small tent, making them perfect for those who prioritize weight in their pack. They also offer more flexibility in setup than a traditional tent.
Equinox vs. Cook Custom Sewing: A Brand Comparison
This review focuses on two American-made brands: Equinox (based in New England) and Cook Custom Sewing (based in Lino Lakes, Minnesota). Both offer high-quality lightweight tarps, but with key differences in size, price, and features. Equinox provides more budget-friendly options, while Cook Custom Sewing offers premium quality and craftsmanship at a higher price point. Both are well-regarded within the outdoor community for their durability and performance.
Tarp Specifications and Pricing
The Equinox tarp measures 6x8 feet, weighs 1 pound 2 ounces, and retails for $36.95. The Cook Custom Sewing tarp is significantly larger at 10x10 feet, weighs 1 pound 15 ounces, and costs $148.50. Both use 1.9-ounce denier ripstop nylon, a durable and lightweight material. The difference in price reflects the superior construction and additional features of the Cook Custom Sewing tarp. Although, higher-denier options are available.
Setup and Ridgeline System
Both tarps can be set up using a ridgeline system, a simple and effective method for creating shelter. This system utilizes paracord, bank line, and lightweight stakes or sticks. The reviewer demonstrates a quick-deployable ridgeline setup, explaining the process using bowlines, trucker's hitches, and prussic knots. This versatile system allows for various configurations, depending on the terrain and desired shelter type.
Cook Custom Sewing Tarp Features
The Cook Custom Sewing tarp distinguishes itself through superior construction. It features reinforced nylon webbing loops at the corners and along the edges, providing numerous attachment points for customizable setups. Internal webbing attachment points and a continuous perimeter webbing further enhance its durability and versatility. Unique to this tarp are four integrated webbing loops designed to accommodate canoe paddles for creating a central support post. This meticulous construction justifies its higher price.
Conclusion and Recommendations
Both the Equinox and Cook Custom Sewing tarps are excellent choices, catering to different needs and budgets. The Equinox tarp is a budget-friendly option, perfect for an emergency shelter or for those seeking a lightweight and versatile tarp at a low price point. The Cook Custom Sewing tarp, however, represents a premium option with exceptional durability and numerous features designed for more demanding outdoor adventures. The choice ultimately depends on individual priorities—budget versus advanced features and superior construction. The ridgeline setup makes both incredibly versatile and easy to use.
