Choosing the right backpacking tent can be a daunting task, especially with so many excellent options available. This detailed comparison focuses on two popular contenders: the MSR Elixir and the Hubba Hubba NX. Both tents offer impressive features and reliable performance, but cater to different needs and priorities. This review will delve into the key differences between these two models, helping you determine which tent best suits your backpacking style and upcoming adventures. We’ll explore weight and pack size, material durability, wind resistance, ventilation, and interior space to provide a comprehensive understanding of their respective strengths and weaknesses.This in-depth analysis will compare the MSR Elixir and Hubba Hubba NX across several crucial aspects, including the weight difference, material composition, structural design, ventilation features, and included accessories. By carefully examining these factors, we aim to equip you with the knowledge needed to make an informed decision. Whether you prioritize ultralight backpacking or require robust durability for challenging conditions, this comparison will illuminate the key distinctions between these two highly-regarded tents, guiding you towards the perfect shelter for your next outdoor excursion.
Read more: 5 Best Family Camping Tents for Your Next Adventure
Pack Size and Weight
The most immediate difference between the MSR Elixir and the Hubba Hubba NX lies in their pack sizes and weights. The Hubba, utilizing lighter materials and a reduced design, boasts a significantly smaller packed volume. This translates to a considerable weight advantage; the Hubba Hubba is 29% lighter than the Elixir, and the Hubba NX is an impressive 37% lighter.
This weight comparison considers the minimum weight, an industry standard that includes the fly, inner tent, poles, pegs, stuff sack, and footprint. This standardized approach allows for a fair comparison between the two tents.
Fabric and Durability
The Hubba series utilizes a lighter 20D nylon fabric, prioritizing weight reduction. In contrast, the Elixir employs a more robust 68D polyester fabric, prioritizing durability. While nylon offers a good balance of weight and strength, polyester excels in tear resistance and water resistance.
Polyester's inherent hydrophobicity means it repels water better and dries faster than nylon. It also resists stretching under tension, a crucial advantage in rainy conditions. This durability makes the Elixir a more suitable choice for less experienced campers and groups prioritizing robust performance.
Pole Structure and Wind Resistance
The Elixir features a two-pole design, offering superior wind resistance compared to the Hubba's single-pole structure. This results in greater stability, especially when facing crosswinds. Both tents include a spreader pole, maximizing interior volume and creating a more spacious feel.
The Elixir's more robust pole system combined with its heavier-duty fabric contributes to its enhanced wind stability. This added stability is a significant factor for those camping in exposed or windy locations.
Ventilation and Features
Both the Elixir and Hubba Hubba series feature kickstand vents at either end of the tent for excellent ventilation and condensation control. The Hubba Hubba’s doors can be rolled up for increased ventilation. High bathtub floors on both provide protection from splashing rain and drafts.
Both tents are designed to allow airflow to minimize condensation. These design features ensure a comfortable and dry sleeping experience, regardless of weather conditions.
Interior Space and Footprint
While interior space is comparable between the two lines, the Elixir's design offers several advantages. The inclusion of a footprint with the Elixir eliminates the need for an additional purchase, unlike the Hubba Hubba. The porch area is also significantly larger on the Elixir.
The Elixir's footprint can be used to increase the tent's interior space significantly, while also prolonging the life of the tent floor. The added volume is about 40% more than the equivalent Hubba Hubba model.
Conclusion: Which Tent is Right for You?
The choice between the MSR Elixir and Hubba Hubba ultimately depends on individual priorities. The Hubba Hubba prioritizes lightweight backpacking, sacrificing some durability and wind resistance for a smaller pack size. The Elixir prioritizes strength and durability and includes a footprint.
The Elixir is a more robust and durable option, ideal for less experienced campers or challenging conditions. However, the Hubba Hubba is a better choice for those who prioritize ultralight backpacking. Both offer excellent waterproof protection and ventilation.
