Headlamp Showdown: Black Diamond Spot, Led Lenser H7R, and Icon Compared

Choosing the right headlamp can be crucial for various activities, from everyday tasks to demanding outdoor adventures. This review compares three popular headlamps: the Black Diamond Spot, the Led Lenser H7R, and the Black Diamond Icon, examining their strengths and weaknesses to help you make an informed decision. We’ll delve into factors such as brightness, battery life, portability, and ease of use, providing a detailed comparison to highlight the ideal headlamp for your specific needs.This head-to-head showdown analyzes each headlamp's performance across a range of criteria, allowing you to weigh the pros and cons effectively. We explore the Black Diamond Spot's lightweight design and everyday practicality, contrast it with the Led Lenser H7R's powerful illumination and long battery life, and examine the Black Diamond Icon's balance between power and portability. Ultimately, this review aims to guide you towards selecting the perfect headlamp for your unique requirements, whether you prioritize power, portability, or a balance of both.

Pros And Cons

Black Diamond Spot
  • Good for working on a car, camping trips
  • Light and simple
  • Dimmable
  • Red light option
  • Lock-on feature
  • Doesn't pack as much power as the Led Lenser H7R
  • Cheap cheesy little retaining system
  • Housing that pops is sucky
  • Can turn on in bag if not locked
Led Lenser H7R
  • Powerful
  • Spotlight and floodlight options
  • Dimmable
  • Long run time
  • Rechargeable
  • Good for bow fishing
  • Great red night vision
  • Hums when on
  • Gets hot
  • Heavy
  • Three straps needed due to weight
Black Diamond Icon
  • Lasts forever
  • Simple battery replacement
  • Water resistant
  • Less concentrated beam than Led Lenser H7R
  • Night vision is weak

Read more: Headlamp Review: Black Diamond, Petzl, Coast & More - Best Hunting Headlamps 2024

Black Diamond Spot: The Everyday Carry Champ

The Black Diamond Spot is a lightweight and simple headlamp, perfect for everyday use. Its dimmable feature and red light option make it versatile for various tasks. It's incredibly easy to pack, easily fitting into a small pouch or bag.

Close-up of the Black Diamond Spot headlamp
Close-up of the Black Diamond Spot headlamp

While not as powerful as the Led Lenser H7R, its simplicity and portability make it ideal for everyday carry. I keep mine in my 'everyday gear bag' for quick access when needed. The compact size and ease of use are its greatest strengths.

The Black Diamond Spot headlamp in an everyday carry bag
The Black Diamond Spot headlamp in an everyday carry bag

Led Lenser H7R: The Powerhouse Performer

The Led Lenser H7R is a powerhouse, significantly brighter and with a more concentrated beam than the Black Diamond Spot. Its rechargeable battery offers impressive runtime; I've used it for two consecutive nights without issue.

The Led Lenser H7R headlamp with its charging port visible.
The Led Lenser H7R headlamp with its charging port visible.

This headlamp excels for activities demanding high brightness and a focused beam, such as bow fishing. The dimmable feature and multiple light modes offer great flexibility, making it suitable for a wide range of situations.

The Led Lenser H7R being used for bow fishing
The Led Lenser H7R being used for bow fishing

Black Diamond Icon: A Versatile Mid-Range Option

The Black Diamond Icon headlamp offers a good balance between power and portability. It features a brighter, more concentrated beam compared to the Black Diamond Spot, making it ideal for tasks where greater illumination is needed. It is also dimmable with red light mode.

The Black Diamond Icon headlamp
The Black Diamond Icon headlamp

While not as bright or long-lasting as the Led Lenser H7R, the Icon provides solid performance at a more moderate price point. Its simple, user-friendly design is another plus.

The Black Diamond Icon with its long run time
The Black Diamond Icon with its long run time

Head-to-Head Comparison and Conclusion

For overall performance and versatility, the Led Lenser H7R takes the lead. Its brightness, long runtime, and rechargeable battery make it a top contender. However, the noticeable hum at full brightness is a significant drawback.

Comparison shot of all three headlamps
Comparison shot of all three headlamps

The Black Diamond Spot excels as a lightweight and compact everyday carry option. Its simplicity and portability are its strongest points. The Black Diamond Icon offers a solid middle ground but doesn't quite match the power of the Led Lenser or the compact portability of the Spot.

The Led Lenser H7R with the hum mentioned
The Led Lenser H7R with the hum mentioned

Ultimately, the best headlamp for you depends on your specific needs. Consider the power required, portability, and desired features before making a decision. I personally choose the Led Lenser H7R for its power, despite the hum, but recommend considering the others based on your prioritized needs.

Final comparison shot
Final comparison shot