Choosing the right tarp can make or break your outdoor adventure. This comparison dives deep into two popular options from Aqua Quest: the Safari and Guide tarps, both available in a versatile 10x13 foot size. While seemingly similar at first glance, these tarps boast key differences in design, material, and features that significantly impact their suitability for various camping styles and weather conditions. This in-depth review will analyze their strengths and weaknesses, helping you determine which tarp best aligns with your needs, whether you prioritize lightweight backpacking gear or robust, all-weather protection.We'll dissect the variations in shape and resulting setup options, comparing material thickness and its effect on durability and wind resistance. Further comparisons will cover tie-out systems, seam construction, included stuff sacks, and overall packability. By the end of this showdown, you'll have a clear understanding of the subtle yet impactful distinctions between the Aqua Quest Safari and Guide tarps, empowering you to make an informed purchase decision that enhances your next outdoor excursion.
Read more: 5 Best PVC Camping Tarps for Your Next Adventure
Tarp Size and Shape Comparison
Both the Aqua Quest Safari and Guide tarps are available in a 10x13 foot size. However, the Safari tarp is wider than it is long, offering a different footprint than the Guide tarp, which is longer than it is wide. This difference is crucial in how you'd set them up for different weather conditions and shelter configurations.
The shape difference affects how you orient the tarp to minimize stress on the seams. The Safari's seams are reinforced along the ridgeline, making a specific orientation ideal for maximizing durability. Similar considerations apply to the Guide tarp's construction.
The orientation choice also impacts the overall shelter configuration and how much space you have. Consider the difference when deciding which shape would best suit your camping style and needs.
Material Thickness and Weight
A noticeable difference lies in the material thickness. The Safari tarp feels thicker and more substantial than the Guide tarp, suggesting greater durability. This difference is reflected in the weight, although exact figures would need to be measured.
The thicker material of the Safari tarp contributes to its superior wind resistance in comparison to the lighter Guide tarp. While both tarps offer adequate protection, the Safari provides a more robust barrier against harsh weather conditions.
The weight difference is a significant factor for backpackers and hikers prioritizing lightweight gear. The Guide tarp emerges as the preferable choice for minimizing pack weight on extended trips.
Tie-Out System and Features
Both tarps feature a tie-out system, but their designs differ. The Safari tarp boasts three intermediate tie-out points along the ridgeline, providing more adjustment options for pitch and tension, while the Guide tarp has only one.
The Safari tarp also includes a loop for hanging items, a useful addition absent in the Guide tarp. Although small, this detail can enhance functionality without adding significant weight.
The tie-out placement on the Guide tarp could be improved by adding more points along the ridgeline for better tension control and versatility. The Safari tarp's reinforced end tie-outs also provide superior strength over the guide tarp's less reinforced construction.
Seams and Construction
Both tarps are seam-taped for waterproofing, but the Safari tarp has an additional seam running perpendicular to the tarp's length. While this doesn't seem to negatively impact performance, it's a noteworthy difference in construction.
The Guide tarp has a single piece of nylon fabric for its main body, creating a cleaner, potentially stronger design. While the Safari tarp's seam is well-constructed and taped, the Guide's continuous panel could potentially add to its overall durability.
The choice between these constructions should depend on priorities between weight, simplicity, and potential added durability. Both tarps are ultimately well-made and water resistant.
Stuff Sack and Overall
Both tarps come with color-matched stuff sacks. However, the Safari tarp's stuff sack is notably too small, making packing a challenge. The Guide tarp's sack is better-sized.
The Safari tarp’s olive drab/brownish tan color contrasts nicely with the Guide tarp’s bright green. Both are visually appealing, but personal preference will dictate the ideal color choice for your purposes.
Packing these tarps is extremely difficult, so keep that in mind when making your purchase decision.
Conclusion: Which Tarp to Choose?
The best tarp depends on individual needs and priorities. The Guide tarp's lightweight design makes it ideal for backpacking trips where weight is paramount, despite its slightly less durable construction.
The Safari tarp offers increased durability and features like the lantern loop, making it a suitable option for day trips, car camping, or those willing to sacrifice some weight for extra sturdiness.
Ultimately, both the Aqua Quest Safari and Guide tarps represent high-quality options from a reputable brand. Carefully consider your needs and priorities to make an informed decision.